The framework / 01

The approach

Plain Risk is an approach to understanding, describing, and managing risk.

Risk

A risk is a possibility of harm or loss. A risk description makes clear what could happen, who or what could be affected, and in which circumstances.

Plain Risk helps people explain what is at stake, what they know, what remains uncertain, and what they are prepared to accept.

Purpose

Plain Risk aims to help people understand risks and examine the grounds for assessing and responding to them. It helps develop descriptions and statements that others can easily understand, challenge, or use in their work.

The description of a situation will affect what people will focus on in this situation. We ask what could happen, why it would matter, and what could be done about it.

Objectives

The objectives of Plain Risk are to enable users to:

  • Describe risks simply and clearly, including what could happen and how it could happen.
  • Explain what measures are intended to achieve, analyse how they work, and assess if they are well designed and effective.
  • Articulate what risks an organisation is prepared to accept and who may authorise to take risks.

Concepts and description

The same situation can be described in different ways. The concepts we use shape what we are saying about it, with implications for which risks we identify, how we assess them, and how we respond.

Risk frameworks ask users to describe actions and situations under headings or categories, such as causes, events, consequences, and controls. Applying a framework therefore requires judgement about both the description and the category under which it belongs. The description of an action or situation will impact on our assessment of it. Plain Risk makes these concepts and relationships explicit so that users can understand the descriptions on which their assessments depend.

See an example

A restaurant sends the head chef home as he is unwell. This action can make two contributions into a risk assessment.

  • “Food contamination could make customers ill”: in this regard, sending the chef home is a control.
  • “Staff shortages could delay service”: in this regard, sending the chef home contributes to the shortage.

The action is the same, but its place in the assessment changes with the description. Seeing both helps the manager both prevent customers from being ill due to the chef and arrange a replacement. Calling the action a 'control' alone could hide the further problem created by the implementation of the control.

Method

We start with simple, clear concepts. Concepts help us identify what is involved in a given situation. We use concise, structured definitions and sentence patterns to explain their meaning and connections. Models represent how things are done or happen, identifying relevant elements and relationships. A model can show an event, the loss it could cause, and the person who could suffer that loss. A sentence pattern or a diagram can express these connections. You can use either form to examine what might happen and who could be affected.

To visualise the models used in Plain Risk, we draw simple diagrams with nodes (also called vertices) and connections (also called edges). Nodes represent the elements of a model, e.g., an event, harm or loss, or a control. Connections show how these elements relate to each other, e.g., an event could lead to harm or loss. Connections will have an arrow to indicate a direction where appropriate, e.g., a control is intended to prevent a particular harm or loss. These diagrams complement sentence patterns by helping users describe a risk and analyse its structure.

Two nodes (vertices) joined by a connection (edge)

This approach draws on J. L. Austin’s work on ordinary language and on Charles J. Fillmore’s account of semantic frames.

A simple pattern makes a relationship explicit: an event could cause a loss; someone takes a precaution for a particular purpose; someone authorises an activity subject to conditions.

These models can be combined to examine a situation. A possible loss can be considered alongside what could cause it, what a precaution is intended to achieve, and what would justify proceeding. Cases help test the account and show what changes when the circumstances change.

We encourage you to apply Plain Risk to situations that matter to you professionally or otherwise. It is designed to help you identify risks, understand how they arise, and assess if the responses to them are appropriate in the circumstances.

Importance

Risk descriptions and appetite statements influence decisions about what to undertake, what to protect, and what precautions to take. Their wording can affect how people understand their authority and responsibilities.

Shared understanding matters to risk governance and risk culture. People need to understand what risks have been identified, what is acceptable, what has been authorised, and what is expected of them. Knowing the same facts can still leave differences in how their significance is understood.

Benefits

Plain Risk supports analytical thinking, shared understanding, and reflection on professional practice.

Analytical and critical thinking

The framework provides a method for clarifying concepts, making distinctions, examining relationships, and comparing alternatives. These activities are central to critical thinking. The method supports users in identifying implicit or missing assumptions, analysing risks, and evaluating reasons.

Shared understanding

Simple, clear concepts provide a common and accessible starting point for discussion. The concepts provided help people clarify what they mean, check how expressions apply to a particular situation, and identify the grounds of agreement or disagreement.

Reflective practice

The framework provides simple models within contemporary risk management practice. These models allow users to describe familiar risk management arrangements, make their assumptions explicit, and compare different professional approaches on that basis.

An open-minded approach

The framework encourages users to consider alternative descriptions and situations. This may lead them to revise their views on the adequacy of certain risk management arrangements.

Taken together, the framework and associated tools provide a practical basis for developing judgement in risk management.

Plain Risk, developed by Dr Julien Maréchal. © 2026 The Governance Practice.

Original materials: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 InternationalCC BY 4.0. Source. Scope and attribution.

Logos, third-party material, and website software are excluded.